Tag Archives: media bias

White American present at Boston, Paris, & Brussels attacks… and he’s not a suspect

Standard

Having finally obtained a degree in Journalism & Media Studies (and having worked at multiple news outlets along the way), I can’t emphasize enough how manipulative news outlets can be in affecting our perceptions of current events.

While treading through late-night Twitter looking for commentary to retweet onto my woefully ignored feed, I came across a few tweets pointing out an insane double standard in coverage of the recent tragedy in Brussels. The tweets linked to an article entitled “Mormon Missionaries From Utah Among Belgian Bombing Survivors”. The article talks about three Mormon Elders who were injured in the attacks.

Here’s an excerpt about one of the missionaries, 19-year-old Mason Wells who is having surgery for damage to his foot, that makes it more interesting:

This was not Wells’ first brush with terror. He was in Boston to watch his mother run the marathon in 2013 when two Chechen immigrant brothers set off shrapnel-filled bombs that killed three and wounded scores more, his family said.

Wells was also in Paris this past November when the French capital was attacked by Belgium-based terrorists, the family said.

 

Screen Shot 2016-03-23 at 2.15.06 ق.د.

Mason Wells, 19-year-old American present at Boston, Paris, & Brussels attacks.

What the hell, NBC? You get a hold of a guy who was present at three recent terror attacks that completely dominated headlines, and you choose to make the story about how three missionaries were hurt?? Talk about burying the lede!

But that’s just it. This wasn’t the lede. These two paragraphs were so nonchalantly nestled in the middle of the article that it would be easy for readers to miss them. Imagine if this man was Muslim instead of Mormon, or even just of a Middle Eastern, South Asian, Eastern European, or African background.

What would be the headline then?

Speaking as a journalist, as someone who’s studied media and criticized the hell out of it, as someone who constantly consumes it, this is the kind of story that media outlets thrive on. In the aftermath of the Boston Marathon bombings, social media took to identifying suspects simply from video of the bombings (and news outlets predictably followed suit in reporting on these). These misidentifications led to multiple people fearing for their safety. Most infamous was Sunil Tripathi, an Indian-American student who had been missing for a month prior to the bombings and became a “stand out suspect” after social media users, most notably on Reddit and Twitter, posted about it. Sunil was found dead days later, and his family could have done without having to deal with these baseless accusations on top of his disappearance.

When people like Sunil and his family are subjected to the witch hunts like this, how is it that a man who was present at three different attacks is barely given notice?

I’m not saying he should be subjected to a witch hunt too (because he shouldn’t), but the difference is striking. I do see a few articles covering the story from this angle, but how is it that a major news outlet like NBC is not? A post on the front page of Imgur makes light of the situation, whereas if the man were of a non-white background, they’d be expressing suspicion instead (as with Boston). Even moving on from news outlets and social media, why isn’t any government looking into this?

I’m not being a conspiracy theorist here (although conspiracies do exist and go read a book about the CIA if you think otherwise). I assure you that, were this man not a white American, I would still say this needs to be looked into. I’m also not saying he’s definitely involved, so don’t be like the Redditors who screwed it up with the Boston bombings. I’m just saying you need to pay attention to how biased your news outlets and your governments are. And you need to demand that they change.

Starting out at the Daily Targum

Standard

I’m not going to waste your time trying to explain who I am and how I’m trying to make some sort of difference in the world or portray my own views on something… You’ll figure out all those things as (or rather, if) you follow along.  My name is Syjil Ashraf.  I’m a Pakistani-American freshman undergraduate student at Rutgers University in New Brunswick, New Jersey on a pre-med track with a major in Journalism & Media Studies.  No, I don’t want to do anything like Sanjay Gupta.  I just like writing and I also happen to want to be a physician.  Two separate things.

Rutgers’ college newspaper is a student-run publication that is unaffiliated with the university. My first article was published in today’s (or technically yesterday’s) issue.  Rutgers hosted a panel on anti-Semitism and Islamophobia in the media with speakers Jack Shaheen, Professor Emeritus of Mass Communication at Southern Illinois University and author of Reel Bad Arabs, and Kenneth Stern, defense attorney, director of anti-Semitism, extremism, and hate studies for the American Jewish Committee and author of Antisemitism, and you can find my report on the event here.

Shaheen was a very well-spoken, quite interesting man… Very passionate.  Stern, I’m sorry to say, bored me somewhat and I tried hard to write giving the anti-Semitism side of the panel fair coverage so as not to look like the typical biased Muslim.  Truth is, Shaheen just owned him.  I’m glad, he did though… To be frank, anti-Semitism really is not a problem within the media.  Islamophobia is the new plague.

Typically, the editors edited out one of my favorite lines.  During the program, Shaheen mentioned William Shirer, a war correspondent in Berlin in the mid-1930s who was aware of what was happening to the Jews, but played it down out of fear of German spies and the fact that the United States government was not willing to hear of the atrocities.  Shaheen felt this did not fall in line with true journalistic integrity.

“If you’re going to be a journalist and you’re going to be in the city, and you can’t tell the truth, what are you doing here? Lose your job, get out.  If you have integrity, tell the truth and let them fire you.”

Shaheen’s words, which I identify with as my own journalistic philosophy, called to mind the downfall of one NBC News correspondent after comments calling out American media for its unfair and pernicious targeting of a “certain demographic”… Ashleigh Banfield.

At one point, Clement Price, the moderator of the panel and apparently “the foremost authority” on black history in New Jersey as well as professor of History at RU-Newark, asked Shaheen “There’s a perception among many Americans that there are no vocal moderate Muslims. Can you speak to this?”  Shaheen straight up told him, “Well, there aren’t…The problem is that those Muslims who want to speak out and who are highly capable of speaking out are not given the opportunity to speak out.”

I guess I’m here to try and change that.

Ab imo pectore,

Syjil

If the above link doesn’t work, here is the URL for the article on the Targum website: http://www.dailytargum.com/news/university/authors-discuss-media-bias-on-middle-east/article_8f5fc42a-fa04-11e0-8b57-0019bb30f31a.html